Choosing workshop management software is one of those decisions that can make or break your daily operations. Pick the right system and you'll wonder how you ever survived without it. Pick the wrong one and you'll spend months fighting against software that doesn't fit how you work.
This guide walks you through exactly what to consider, what questions to ask, and how to evaluate your options. We'll be honest about what matters and what's just marketing fluff.
What We'll Cover
Before You Start Looking
Before comparing software options, you need clarity on your own situation. Answer these questions first:
1. What's Your Budget?
Most workshop management software is priced monthly, typically ranging from $35 to $200+ depending on features and users. According to industry data, a typical entry-level plan is around $100-120 per month.
Consider:
- Base monthly cost
- Per-user fees (some charge extra for each team member)
- Setup or onboarding fees
- Training costs
2. How Many Users Do You Need?
Some platforms charge per user. If you have 5 staff, those per-user fees add up fast. Others offer flat-fee pricing where your whole team is included.
3. What's Your Must-Have Integration?
For most NZ workshops, Xero integration is non-negotiable. If you use MYOB or QuickBooks, confirm compatibility before going further.
4. Cloud or Desktop?
Cloud-based systems are the standard now. Benefits include:
- Access from anywhere on any device
- Automatic backups
- No IT maintenance
- Always up to date
Desktop software still exists but is increasingly rare. Unless you have specific offline requirements, cloud is the way to go.
Must-Have Features
These are the features every workshop management system should have. If a platform is missing any of these, keep looking.
Job/Work Order Management
Create, track, and manage repair orders from start to finish. This is the core of any workshop system.
Customer & Vehicle Database
Store customer details and complete vehicle history. Should auto-populate from previous visits.
Invoicing
Create professional invoices, track payments, and send receipts. Should integrate with your accounting software.
Accounting Integration
Xero sync is essential for NZ businesses. Invoices should flow automatically without double-entry.
For NZ Workshops Specifically
- WoF reminder system: Automated reminders for Warrant of Fitness expiry
- Vehicle lookup: Ability to pull vehicle details from registration number
- GST handling: Proper NZ tax compliance
Nice-to-Have Features
These aren't essential, but can add real value depending on your workflow:
| Feature | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Digital Vehicle Inspection (DVI) | Photos/videos of issues build trust and can increase repair approvals by 20%+ |
| Online Booking | Customers book themselves - one less phone call for you |
| SMS/Email Notifications | Automatic updates keep customers informed without you calling |
| Parts Supplier Integration | Order parts directly from the system with live pricing |
| Inventory Management | Track stock levels, set reorder points, manage purchase orders |
| Technician Time Tracking | See how long jobs actually take vs quoted time |
| Reporting & Analytics | Track revenue, job profitability, and technician efficiency |
Understanding Pricing Models
Workshop software typically uses one of these pricing structures:
Flat Monthly Fee
One price includes everything and everyone. Best for: workshops with multiple staff who don't want to pay per-user.
Per-User Pricing
Base fee plus additional cost for each user. Can add up quickly in larger teams.
Tiered Plans
Different feature sets at different prices. Be careful - sometimes basic features are locked behind higher tiers.
What to Watch For
- Hidden setup or onboarding fees
- Long-term contracts (many offer month-to-month)
- Limits on number of jobs, invoices, or customers
- Extra charges for SMS credits or storage
Calculate Total Cost of Ownership
Don't just compare base prices. Calculate your total monthly cost including all users, any add-ons you need, and integration fees. A "cheap" base plan can become expensive once you add what you actually need.
Questions to Ask Vendors
Before committing, ask these questions:
About the Product
- Can I see a demo with my actual workflow (not a canned presentation)?
- What happens to my data if I leave?
- How often do you release updates?
- What's your uptime/reliability track record?
About Support
- What support is included? Phone, email, chat?
- What are your support hours? (Critical for NZ timezone)
- Is training included or extra?
- Is there documentation I can access?
About Migration
- Can you import my existing customer and vehicle data?
- What formats do you accept?
- Is there a cost for data migration?
- How long does typical migration take?
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake 1: Choosing Based on Price Alone
The cheapest option isn't always the best value. Software that saves you 10 hours a month is worth paying more for. At a $100/hour shop rate, that's $1,000/month in recovered time.
Mistake 2: Not Actually Testing It
Don't choose based on demos and feature lists. Use the free trial. Create real jobs. Send real invoices. Test with your actual workflow.
Mistake 3: Ignoring Your Team
Your techs and service writers will use this daily. Get their input. A system you love but they hate will fail.
Mistake 4: Overcomplicating It
More features isn't always better. A simpler system you actually use beats a complex system you fight against.
Mistake 5: Not Planning Migration
Switching software is disruptive. Plan for a few weeks of transition. Don't expect perfection on day one.
The Evaluation Process
A recommended approach:
Step 1: Define Your Requirements (1 week)
List must-haves vs nice-to-haves. Set your budget. Identify your deal-breakers.
Step 2: Research Options (1 week)
Create a shortlist of 2-3 options. Don't try to evaluate 10 platforms - you'll get overwhelmed.
Step 3: Trial Each Option (2 weeks)
Actually use them. Create test jobs, customers, invoices. Use real scenarios from your workshop.
Step 4: Involve Your Team (1 week)
Get feedback from anyone who'll use the system. Their input matters.
Step 5: Make Your Decision
Choose based on fit, not just features. The best software is the one your team will actually use.
The Right Software Pays for Itself
Industry data suggests the right workshop management software can reduce admin time by 40-50%. For a busy shop, that's potentially 10+ hours per week back in productive time. At your shop rate, that's significant money.
The Bottom Line
Choosing workshop software comes down to three things:
- Fit: Does it match how your workshop actually operates?
- Value: Does the benefit justify the cost?
- Usability: Will your team actually use it?
Don't rush the decision, but don't overthink it either. Most modern platforms handle the basics well. Your job is to find the one that feels right for your specific situation.
Looking for NZ-Focused Workshop Software?
Hoist is built in New Zealand, for New Zealand workshops. Native NZTA integration, Xero sync, and simple flat-fee pricing.
Try Hoist Free for 14 Days