When someone searches “mechanic near me”, the workshops with more reviews and higher ratings show up first and get the clicks. But asking for reviews feels awkward, and most happy customers never think to leave one.
This guide covers practical ways to get more reviews without annoying your customers, what to say, and how to handle the bad ones.
In this guide
Why Google Reviews Matter for Workshops
1. They Affect Your Search Ranking
Google uses reviews as a ranking factor for local search. More reviews (and higher ratings) push you higher in results for searches like:
- “Mechanic near me”
- “Car service [your suburb]”
- “WoF [your town]”
In our experience a workshop with 50 reviews usually outranks one with 5, even if the smaller shop does better work.
2. They Build Trust Before the First Call
People are handing over their car, often their second most valuable asset, to a stranger. BrightLocal’s consumer survey puts it at 75% of consumers regularly reading reviews before choosing a local business. When someone sees “great communication, fair pricing, fixed the issue first time” from 30 different people, they’re more likely to pick up the phone.
3. They’re Free Advertising That Keeps Working
Unlike paid ads that stop the moment you stop paying, reviews stick around. A review from three years ago still influences customers today. Every review is a permanent asset for your business.
The Numbers Game
Say you service 20 cars a week and 10% of the customers you ask leave a review (in our experience somewhere between 5% and 15% do). That’s 2 reviews a week, or 100+ a year. Most workshops never ask, so they sit on 10-20 reviews total. Consistent asking compounds.
When to Ask for Reviews
Timing matters more than the ask itself. Get it right and customers are happy to help. Get it wrong and you seem desperate.
The Best Moments to Ask
| Moment | Why It Works | Effectiveness |
|---|---|---|
| Right after pickup | Customer is relieved, car is fixed, goodwill is high | Best |
| After positive feedback | “Glad you’re happy. Would you mind sharing that on Google?” | Best |
| Same-day text/email | Experience is fresh, easy to action on their phone | Great |
| Follow-up call (next day) | “Just checking everything’s good. By the way...” | Great |
| A week later | Too late. They’ve moved on mentally | Poor |
Who to Ask
Everyone. Ask every customer whose job is done, the same way, with the same link. Don’t pick favourites and don’t try to guess who’ll give five stars: Google calls selectively asking happy customers “review gating” and prohibits it (more on that below), and you need volume anyway. A mix of 4 and 5-star reviews reads as real; a wall of identical 5-stars from a handful of mates doesn’t.
The one practical exception: a customer with an unresolved problem. Sort the problem first, then ask them too. Leave people who are clearly in a rush for the follow-up text rather than the counter.
How to Ask for Reviews
The key is making it easy and not making it weird. Here are methods that work:
Method 1: The In-Person Ask
When a customer picks up their car:
“Glad we could sort that for you. If you’ve got a minute, we’d really appreciate a Google review. It helps other people find us. I can text you the link if that’s easier?”
Key elements:
- Acknowledge the completed work: “Glad we could sort that”
- Make a direct ask: don’t hint, ask clearly
- Explain why: “helps other people find us”
- Offer to make it easy: “I can text you the link”
Method 2: The Follow-Up Text
Send the same day, ideally within a few hours of pickup:
Hi [Name], thanks for choosing [Workshop Name] today. If you’re happy with the service, we’d really appreciate a quick Google review. It only takes a minute and helps us heaps.
[Direct link to your Google review page]
Thanks, [Your name]
The direct link is crucial. Don’t make them search for you; every extra step loses people.
Method 3: The Email Follow-Up
Works well for larger jobs or commercial customers:
Subject: How was your service at [Workshop Name]?
Hi [Name],
Thanks for bringing your [vehicle] in for [service type]. We hope everything’s running smoothly.
If you were happy with the service, we’d really appreciate a Google review. It takes about 30 seconds and helps local customers find us.
[Leave a Review button/link]
If anything’s not right, please get in touch and we’ll sort it out.
The last line is ordinary customer service, not a filter: everyone gets the same message and the same link.
Method 4: QR Code at the Counter
Create a QR code that links directly to your Google review page. Put it:
- On the counter where people pay
- On a small card you hand out with keys
- On the bottom of invoices
This is passive but catches some customers. Works best combined with a verbal mention: “If you scan that QR code, it takes you straight to our reviews page.”
Getting Your Google Review Link
The easiest way is the short link Google gives you:
- Sign in to Google Business Profile
- Click “Ask for reviews” (or find “Get more reviews” in your profile)
- Copy the short link provided and use it in texts, emails and your QR code
Or build it yourself: search for your business on Google, click your listing, click “Write a review” and copy that URL; or use Google’s Place ID tool. The URL looks something like:
https://search.google.com/local/writereview?placeid=YOUR_PLACE_ID
What Not to Do
Don’t Offer Incentives
Offering discounts, free services, or any reward for reviews violates Google’s terms. If caught, Google can remove all your reviews or suspend your listing. Not worth the risk.
Don’t Buy Fake Reviews
Those services offering “50 reviews for $100” are scams that will get you penalised. Google’s algorithms detect fake reviews, and competitors can report you.
Don’t Ask Multiple Times
One ask is fine. Following up once is okay if they said they would. Beyond that, you’re annoying them. Accept that most people won’t leave reviews; that’s normal.
Don’t Gate Reviews
“Review gating” means only directing happy customers to Google while sending unhappy ones elsewhere. Google explicitly prohibits this. You can’t ask “Were you happy? Yes → leave a Google review, No → contact us privately.” Ask everyone, send everyone the same link, and handle problems through normal customer service.
Responding to Reviews
Respond to every review, good and bad. Potential customers read your responses to see what you’re like to deal with.
Positive Reviews
Keep it short, personal, and specific to the job. Avoid copy-paste replies.
Good Response Examples:
- “Thanks Sarah! Glad we could sort out that brake issue for you. See you next time.”
- “Cheers Mike, appreciate the kind words. Hope the Ranger is treating you well!”
- “Thanks for the review, John. Always good to see repeat customers. Drive safe!”
Negative Reviews
Bad reviews happen to every business. How you respond matters more than the review itself.
Bad Response
“This is completely false. You were rude to our staff and refused to pay for work we completed. We don’t want customers like you anyway.”
Defensive, argumentative, unprofessional. Makes the business look worse than the original review.
Good Response
“Hi [Name], we’re sorry your experience didn’t meet expectations. We take feedback seriously and would like to understand what went wrong. Please contact us at [phone/email] so we can make this right.”
Acknowledges the issue, offers resolution, moves the conversation offline.
Response Template for Negative Reviews
Hi [Name],
Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your experience; this isn’t the standard we aim for.
We’d like to look into this and make it right. Please contact [name] on [phone] or email us at [email] so we can discuss.
[Your name], [Workshop name]
When to Respond (and When Not To)
Always respond to:
- Legitimate complaints about service
- Misunderstandings you can clarify professionally
- Reviews mentioning specific staff or issues
Consider not responding to:
- Obviously fake reviews from non-customers (report these instead)
- Abusive or defamatory content (report to Google)
- Reviews where any response will escalate the situation
Can You Get Negative Reviews Removed?
Google will only remove reviews that violate their policies:
- Fake or spam reviews
- Off-topic content
- Restricted content (illegal, adult, etc.)
- Conflict of interest (competitors, ex-employees)
A real bad review from a real customer, even an unfair one, won’t be removed. Your response is your only recourse.
Building a Review System
The workshops with the most reviews ask consistently. Here’s how to build that in:
Option 1: Manual Process
- Train all front-desk staff on when and how to ask
- Keep review cards at the counter
- Send a follow-up text to every customer the same day as pickup
- Track how many reviews you get weekly
Pros: No cost, full control
Cons: Easy to forget, relies on staff consistency
Option 2: A Template in Your Workshop Software
Save the follow-up text above as an SMS template in your workshop software, with your review link in it, and send it from the job card when you invoice. It takes two taps, it goes to every customer, and nobody has to remember the wording. In Hoist that’s an SMS template sent from the job; the customer’s name and vehicle fill in from the job card.
What the template needs:
- The customer’s first name and your workshop name
- Your direct Google review link (the short link above)
- One sentence, no hard sell
Tracking Progress
Set a baseline and track monthly:
- How many reviews did you start with?
- How many new reviews this month?
- What’s your average rating?
- How many negative reviews and what were the themes?
A simple spreadsheet works. The act of tracking makes you more likely to keep asking.
Quick Wins to Start Today
Your 15-Minute Action Plan
- □ Get your Google review short link
- □ Save a text template for follow-ups
- □ Print a QR code for the counter
- □ Ask 3 customers this week as practice
- □ Respond to any unanswered reviews
Send the Ask From the Job Card
Save a review-request text in your Hoist SMS templates and send it from the job card when you close the job. One less thing to remember at the counter.
Start Free Trial